No, that is correct...
If an item retails at £5.99 and has a 17.5% VAT rate, the VAT content is 89p
Or it's £5.10 exc VAT, £5.10 + 17.5% VAT (5.10 x 1.175) = £5.99
That said, awful long time since I did A Level Maths 
Get free EPoS software at http://www.lettronics.com